Last night I watched the movie "Milk." (Quite a well done film: good acting, nicely written script, well edited...and of course,
the story....) Obviously the end of the movie gun violence was no surprise; like most of us, I recalled the main points of the story. But what did surprise me was its reminder to me of an incredulity I have held since I was a teenager.
After the movie I said to BZ, "I have a stupid question....Why is it that we still allow guns to be so available in this country?" His answer did not make me feel stupid but it didn't elucidate the issue either. He responded with things I've heard before....'American tradition...the Second Amendment'....Stuff like that....
I still don't understand....I never have. I have vague recollections of debating this issue, both formally and informally, in high school and college and law school. It always seemed to me that it was like religion: people believed what they wanted to believe, what their faith led them to believe, and were not about to be swayed by someone else's facts.
I get this. But I still have the same questions: How can it make sense for guns to be so readily available? How is it that a seemingly small minority of "gun owners" can make policy for the rest of us? Especially when that policy is killing us in what seems to be shockingly large numbers....And in the random, senseless killing of people who had no relation at all to the violence other than being in the wrong place at the wrong time....And even if they were "related" (think of domestic violence or gang deaths, etc.), there is something jarring -- and dare I say, "unfair" -- about the thought of it....A burning piece of metal piercing your flesh and then death....
Actually, I discover this morning, it is not a simple matter to find out how large the numbers are. Like most people over the age of nine, when I want to know a fact, I hop on Google. What my searches reveal is not too helpful. One of my first hits is the CDC (Centers for Disease Control) mortality charts. First of all, apparently the most recent data is from 2005 (that's already four years old!) and after plugging in the variables (which were required fields), I'm not exactly sure what number it was spitting out. As far as I can tell, the CDC data shows 12,352 gun deaths in the United States in 2005.
I return to Google. I find a promising looking link to Harvard. An article from 2000 mentioned a pilot study to track gun deaths. But the trail peters out early in the decade and the Harvard site itself doesn't contain links to articles past 2003....Where is this information? I can't help but wonder....Is its paucity related to the whole reason we don't have any meaningful gun control to being with? (Are there some hidden agendas?....)
Anyway, it is perhaps something to think about next time there is a gun death....Four cops in Oakland, someone on television, God forbid...someone we know....Maybe after we're done thinking about health care and the economy and relationships between people and the health and well being of our loved ones, we can think about guns in this nation....Or maybe we should think about it at the same time...because actually it's all related....
(If you're interested, check out: http://www.marinij.com/ci_12126366?source=most_viewed
OR http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/hicrc/nviss/index.htm
OR try your own Google search....)